Want to know what's happening next in healthcare?

MedCityNews is the leading online news source for the business of innovation in healthcare.


“I find MedCity News a great resource for taking the pulse of the market and sourcing potential investment opportunities.”

Bernie Rudnick, Angel investor and advisor, CapGenic Advisors, LLC


Sign up for our daily newsletter


They used it on Truman and now Obama, but is Lenin socialized medicine ‘quote’ real?

October 14, 2013 4:00 am by | 9 Comments

question-marks

It was the most expensive campaign ever launched, but opponents were determined to defeat the president's health care reform plan.

"Would socialized medicine lead to socialization of other phases of American life?" began one of the pitches used in a massive advertising and lobbying effort. "Lenin thought so. He declared: 'Socialized medicine is the keystone to the arch of the Socialized State."

That may sound like it was ripped from today's headlines -- or at least, the debut this week of Fox News' latest talking head, Dr. Ben Carson.

But although the retired Johns Hopkins neurosurgeon has been using the last sentence of that quote to trash Obamacare, it dates back more than 60 years -- from a pamphlet circulated in opposition to another president, Harry Truman, and his own attempt to expand health care coverage.

Advertisement

Some things really never change. Not only is the same red-scare flag being waved today, there's this: Neither then or now, no one seems to have evidence that such a bon mot ever passed Lenin's lips.

"It was a completely made-up quote," Princeton sociologist Paul Starr tells me.

Starr is the author of the 1983 book "The Social Transformation of American Medicine," which won the Pulitzer Prize and a host of other accolades as the definitive history of the country's health care system.

He is also a founder of The American Prospect, a proudly liberal political magazine, which I suppose will give some the license they want to dismiss what he has to say -- a skepticism that funnily enough vanishes when it comes to anything from of the other end of the spectrum.

In any event, Starr's book details how the American Medical Association went full throttle against Truman, charging its members $25 each for a $1.5 million lobbying campaign against his call for a national health insurance system for everyone -- what we now would call a single-payer plan, or basically, Medicare for all ages.

Creeping socialism was a pretty convincing argument in the Cold War years, and the AMA's political consultants organized meetings and put out pamphlets using the alleged Lenin quote.

But as Starr notes in his book, "The Library of Congress could not locate this quotation in Lenin's writings."

I reached out to David Walters, an administrator of an online Lenin archive, to see if he might find have better luck, but he too came up empty.

The closest Walters could get to approximating the sentiment if not the words of the Lenin quote comes from a 1919 party conference in which the leader said hunger, a lack of soap or fuel and "lice that carry typhus" could "prevent our tackling any sort of socialist development."

Walters, who also directs the Holt Labor Library, said it would be out of character for Lenin to say, first we socialize medicine and then everything else. Rather, he advocated seizing governmental power first and then enacting wholesale socialist reforms, Walters said.

Similarly, Mark G. Field, a leading expert on Soviet socialized medicine and professor emeritus of Boston University, has written that the notion of socialized medicine as "a first wedge for the introduction of socialism ... had as much logic as arguing that firehouses cause fires."

Field said when I called him that he had "very great doubts" about the validity of the Lenin quote.

"Lenin had more important areas to worry about," said Field, an associate of the Davis Center for Russian and Eurasian Studies at Harvard. "The priority for Lenin was industrialization and the ability to produce weapons of defense and attack."

I tried to reach Carson through his publicist to ask his source for the Lenin quote, which he used Wednesday on Fox's "The Kelly File" and repeated Friday at the Values Voter Summit in Washington. (There, Carson also said Obamacare was slavery.) I didn't hear back from the publicist, but the Lenin quote can be found on multiple conservative, anti-Obama websites.

On Fox, Carson expanded on the quote by saying, "In other words, you've got to get the socialized medicine as the foundation, because it gives you control of the people. Once you get control of the people, you can do what you want."

Despite its fuzzy origins, the Lenin quote has persisted because it fits "the right-wing mythology," Starr said.

"It really is representative of a larger mythology that the American conservatives have come to believe in," he said, "this idea that by providing a means for everyone to get health insurance is to undermine freedom. It's crazy."

He notes that even if Lenin had said or believed this "keystone" theory, the quote still makes no sense in the current context: "What's being offered isn't socialism," Starr said. "It's private insurance that's offered in the health care exchanges."

And in fact, said Walters, when anyone claims Obama is a socialist, it is the latter who is insulted.

"None of us would ever associate our politics with his, which are designed to save capitalism," Walters said, "not bury it."

[email protected]

twitter.com/jean_marbella ___

Copyright 2014 MedCity News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

By Jean Marbella

Visit website | More posts by Author

9 comments
AngieEstrada
AngieEstrada

Dr. Carson has not suggested that there is anything "new" about using that quote in an attempt to wake people up. Nor has he said there's anything new about the those words or sentiment.

He is quoting a person who knew very well of which he spoke, Vladimir Lenin. Remember him?

I hope Dr. Carson gets more, more, more face-time on every network -- and evey flippin' billboard across this country -- and continues shouting that reminder from the rooftops.

It may prove to be an exercise in futility, given the condition of our "progressive"-infested country. But I hope he never gives up.

Keep it up Dr. Carson. Keep quoting and paraphrasing Lenin - and Stalin, Hitler, Marx et al. Quote Obama himself from "Dreams From My Father" and from his UN addresses.


AngieEstrada
AngieEstrada

Why are my comments not posting? If you believe there is no truth or validity to my comments, then what have you got to hide?

AngieEstrada
AngieEstrada

"Not socialism"? Really, Walters? Capitalism, you say? Forcing private insurance companies to lose many billions of dollars, collectively, by forcing them to cancel million policies to date, is not capitalism. Forcing them out of business and/or into laying off thousands of employees is not capitalism. Good flippin' grief, the logic is so dishonest.

baderpaderp
baderpaderp

Then don't get government subsidized health care, Dave. Get it from your employer like most other Americans that have health insurance.

Big Dave
Big Dave

there is a difference between "providing the means of healthcare" and making it a law punishable by fines if you don't have government subsidized health care! Please see the whole picture. This IS what a dictator state would do, no a republic.

hotrodder3308
hotrodder3308

@AngieEstrada  except apparently that quote Carson is using was never uttered by Lenin.


Maybe you should read the article you are responding too


Veronica Combs
Veronica Combs moderator

@AngieEstrada Hi, Angie. Our comments are moderated - meaning a human reads them before they show up on the site. The delay is not a statement on the validity of the comment.

AngieEstrada
AngieEstrada

@baderpaderp Nobody has a choice of whether or not they "get government subsidized healthcare". Most won't qualify for subsidies.

Government subsidies, i.e., taxpayer paid subsidies, will be available to the very low income (fine) ... and to the scammers ... and to the wealthy members of Congress, the Administration and other government officials. Even those Congress who are not personally rich, receive hefty salaries at the taxpayers' expense. Rich or not, they can afford the cost increases much more easily than the rest of us.

Therefore, not only are we being forced to purchase lesser plans at a higher cost for ourselves, we are also subsidizing ultra-deluxe plans for Gov officials -- plans that we cannot afford for ourselves -- plans which they can very well afford to pay for themselves (from the huge salaries which we also pay).

You truly see nothing wrong with this picture?

And true, most employers will continue to provide coverage for their employees. Many employers are also being forced to purchase the ACA "new and improved" plans -- at a higher cost to both the employer and the employee. Higher premiums and ridiculously high deductibles. Most people will have to spend a fortune before their deductibles are satisfied, i.e., before they receive any so-called "affordable" healthcare.

There is nothing affordable about it to the majority of Americans. People who insist on defending this travesty are either severely misinformed or shamefully disingenuous. One of the two. There is no third option.

Hear the latest news first

Get our daily newsletter or follow us.

Advertisement