Daily

Wearables Final Four: Wearable defibrillator edges out smart bra for breast cancer detection

Heart disease is one of the trio of chronic diseases that the Affordable Care Act aims to improve. Although a portable defibrillator won’t reduce readmissions for heart disease patients and those who have had heart surgery, it can save lives. I am picking ZOLL Medical’s Life Vest over First Warning’s smart bra for a few […]

Heart disease is one of the trio of chronic diseases that the Affordable Care Act aims to improve. Although a portable defibrillator won’t reduce readmissions for heart disease patients and those who have had heart surgery, it can save lives.

I am picking ZOLL Medical’s Life Vest over First Warning’s smart bra for a few reasons.  It adds a safety net for vulnerable patients when they’re discharged from the hospital. The patients who would be prescribed this device tend to be waiting for a heart transplant, recently suffered a myocardial infarction or recently had a procedure such as cardiac bypass surgery or coronary angioplasty.

Although the device was cleared by the FDA several years ago, the company is still seeking indications that would make it more routinely prescribed. It also speaks to wider need for accessible defibrillators to respond to sudden heart attacks.

Readers saw things differently. The smart bra captured 61 percent of the vote and the Life Vest only received 39 percent.

One of the things that I like about First Warning’s smart bra technology is that it can passively alert people to possible problems and poses some interesting ways to reduce breast cancer. It’s also designed to reduce the number of false positives that can lead to unnecessary biopsies. Its CEO sees it fulfilling a need, particularly in women under 40 who have dense breast tissue. It has planned a clinical validation trial in the second half of the year. But ZOLL’s device has the potential to save more people.

Winner: ZOLL Medical

 

presented by