Want to know what's happening next in healthcare?

MedCityNews is the leading online news source for the business of innovation in healthcare.


“MedCity is invaluable among the many sources of industry reporting because the team endeavor to bring the truly new, and innovative opportunities and developments to light.”

Ken Kirby, President, Transdermal Delivery Solutions Corp


Sign up for our daily newsletter


Topic: Health Data

Published in partnership with the Health Data Consortium. The Health Data Consortium is a collaboration among government, non-profit, and private sector organizations working to foster the availability and use of health data to drive innovations that improve health and health care.

Which group is causing more healthcare IT system errors: humans or computers?

February 7, 2013 3:13 pm by | 0 Comments

Hand fist on computer keyboardAs providers race to implement healthcare IT amid calls by some organizations to extend the deadlines for meeting criteria set down by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid, a new report by the Pennsylvania Patient Safety Authority highlighting safety pitfalls could ruffle some feathers.

It raises the question of who or what is responsible for these healthcare system errors being made by providers and other healthcare facilities. Are healthcare professionals still making the same sort of errors they would if they were putting pen to paper medical records or are our plastic and silicon helpers to blame? Or is it a combination of both?

Although computer systems were behind more than half (56 percent) of the errors, humans were not far behind with 44 percent. Of the 211 problems from 171 events surveyed by healthcare facilities, 105 or 61 percent were not caught until they reached the patient. The five most frequently cited problems were:

  • Inad­equate data transfer from one health IT system to another.
  • Data entry in the wrong patient record.
  • Incorrect data entry in the patient record.
  • Failure of the healthcare IT sys­tem to function as intended.
  • Configuration of the system in a way that can lead to mistakes.

As highlighted by an earlier study, medication management was the prime culprit, accounting for more than half of the events (53 percent). For computer problems a little more than one quarter were caused by problems with the system interfaces, preventing healthcare professionals from ordering test findings when they wanted them, delaying the time it took to get them.

Advertisement

For humans, incorrectly entered information or information that wasn’t entered at all was the cause of the majority of errors. What makes the report a little disconcerting is the computerized physician order entry (CPOE) was associated with many of the errors. The absence of an undecipherable scrawl by physicians in this section is supposed to reduce errors. But whether it’s fat fingers or people pushed for time, it’s inevitable that mistakes will be made and more vigilance required.

Although it’s a near cert that using electronic medical records to provide healthcare is the best alternative, some of the things that make them so desirable — transparency, the ability of more people to view the same information and that they are more immediately accessible — also means that any mistakes in these records risks being amplified. In response, it has produced a toolkit to help groups test their systems and a list of what to monitor. I’ll highlight some of those in another story on this report.

 

[Photo credit: Hand fist on computer keyboard from BigStock Photo]

 

Copyright 2014 MedCity News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Stephanie Baum

By Stephanie Baum

Stephanie Baum is the East Coast Innovation Reporter for MedCityNews.com. She enjoys covering healthcare startups across health IT, drug development and medical devices and innovations deployed to improve medical care. She graduated from Franklin & Marshall College in Pennsylvania and has worked across radio, print and video. She's written for The Christian Science Monitor, Dow Jones & Co. and United Business Media.
Visit website | More posts by Author

0 comments

Health Data Consortium

Published in partnership with the Health Data Consortium. The Health Data Consortium is a collaboration among government, non-profit, and private sector organizations working to foster the availability and use of health data to drive innovations that improve health and health care. More information on the Health Data Consortium can be found at HealthDataConsortium.org.


Latest From HDC Blog

#HealthData


Recommended Links

Health Data Consortium

Website | LinkedIn | Twitter

HealthData.gov

Website | Facebook | Twitter

Health Data Initiative Forum

Website


Profiles

Todd Park

United States Chief Technology Officer

Todd Park is the United States Chief Technology Officer and in this role serves as an Assistant to the President. Todd joined the Administration in August 2009 as Chief Technology Officer of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). In this role, he served as a change agent and “entrepreneur-in-residence,” helping HHS harness the power of data, technology, and innovation to improve the health of the nation.


Bryan Sivak

Chief Technology Officer, Department of Health and Human Services

Bryan Sivak joined HHS as the Chief Technology Officer in July 2011. In this role, he is responsible for helping HHS leadership harness the power of data, technology, and innovation to improve the health and welfare of the nation.


Steven Randazzo

Communications Lead for Innovations Team, Department of Health and Human Services

Steven works with the HHS's Chief Technology Officer to promote the formation and adoption of innovative processes and products in government. Steven is the manager of three open data and innovation blogs and his primary duties focus on external communication of the initiatives and priorities undertaken by HHS and outlined in the Open Government Plan.


Jim Cashel

Chairman of Forum One Communications

Forum One Communications is a digital communications firm which works at the nexus of technology, public policy, and online community. With offices in Washington DC, Seattle and San Francisco, Forum One has completed 1000 projects for 300 clients, including foundations, nonprofit organizations, government agencies and commercial groups. Prior to Forum One Jim co-founded the Eurasia Foundation, a Washington, D.C.-based grant-making organization.